Understand your rights under Montana law after an injury at work
What does it mean to say a state is a right-to-work state?
Saying a state is a “right-to-work” state means that the state has laws preventing employers and unions from requiring employees to pay union dues or join a union or as a condition of getting or keeping a job.
Essentially, workers in these states have the choice to support or join a union, but it’s not mandatory for employment.
Is Montana a right-to-work state?
No, Montana is not a right-to-work state.
Here’s an analogy: Think of a union like a sports team. In a right-to-work state, only some players contribute financially (by paying dues) to the team (union).
In a non-right-to-work state (Montana), all players on the team (workplace) contribute, allowing for a potentially stronger team (union) that can negotiate better benefits for all players (workers).
This is because unions and employers can negotiate contracts that include a security clause. This clause allows unions to require all workers in a unionized workplace to either join the union or pay union dues (often called a fair share fee) as a condition of employment.
Just like a stronger team can negotiate better results, a financially secure union can often negotiate better wages, benefits, and working conditions for its members.
Why should people have the right-to-work?
Some believe that workers shouldn’t have to join a union or pay dues to keep their jobs. They argue that workers should be free to decide if a union aligns with their interests.
Additionally, they might object to mandatory dues payments, especially if they disagree with the union’s leadership or actions.
Some also believe individual performance and merit should be the primary factors in promotions and pay raises, not union seniority rules.
Finally, they might argue that mandatory union membership reduces flexibility for employers in managing their workforce.
Montana’s stance on right-to-work bill
Contrary to the growing number of states adopting right-to-work laws, Montana remains a state where such laws are not in place. This means that in Montana, employers and unions can legally negotiate contracts that make union membership or the maintenance of membership a condition of employment.
A proposed right-to-work bill in 2023, which did not pass the state legislature, highlighted Montana’s current approach to worker rights and labor relations.
Montana’s stance on not being a right-to-work state does not mean that workers lack rights regarding unionization. In fact, it’s illegal for employers to engage in any form of threats, coercion, or intimidation to influence an employee’s decision regarding union membership.
This protection ensures that workers can make choices about unionization freely and without fear of retaliation, reinforcing the principles of fairness and respect in the workplace.
How to respond to a toxic work environment
Understand your rights in a hostile workplace in Montana.
Are right-to-work laws related to workers’ comp benefits?
No, there is no direct correlation between right-to-work laws and workers’ compensation benefits.
Workers’ compensation is a mandated state program designed to provide financial assistance to employees who suffer job-related injuries or occupational illnesses, regardless of their union membership status.
This separation keeps workers’ compensation straightforward, ensuring it supports all workers without complications arising from union membership. For instance, even a non-union worker who gets injured on the job can file a claim for workers’ compensation benefits.
Can an injured employee be fired in Montana?
Many U.S. states are considered “at-will” states for employment, meaning that employers can terminate employees at any time for any reason, except for illegal ones, without warning, as long as the reason is not prohibited by law (e.g., discrimination). Similarly, employees can leave their jobs at any time for any reason.
Montana is one of the few states that is not an at-will state. Once an employee completes the probationary period specified by the employer, the Wrongful Discharge From Employment Act (WDEA) requires that the employer must have good cause to terminate the employment.
This law makes Montana an exception to the at-will employment doctrine, providing employees with a greater degree of job security after the probationary period.
Regardless of whether you work in an at-will state or not, firing an employee solely because they suffered a work-related injury or filed a workers’ compensation claim is considered illegal retaliation, which is not considered “good cause” termination. Good cause typically refers to a legitimate business reason unrelated to the injury or claim.
Examples of good cause termination in Montana
Here are some examples of situations that could be considered good cause for termination:
- Performance issues. This can include poor work quality, excessive absenteeism, or failure to meet deadlines after documented warnings and attempts to improve.
- Misconduct. Serious violations of company policies, such as theft, harassment, or violence, can be grounds for termination.
- Insubordination. Refusal to follow lawful instructions from a supervisor can be considered good cause for termination.
- Safety violations. Serious or repeated violations of safety protocols can be grounds for termination if they put the employee or others at risk.
- Company restructuring or downsizing. If a company undergoes layoffs or restructures its operations, job elimination can be a legitimate reason for termination.
What should I do if I was fired after filing a workers’ comp claim in Montana?
If you believe you’ve been wrongfully terminated after suffering a work-related injury or filing a workers’ comp claim in Montana, here’s what you need to do:
- Keep documentation. Maintain copies of all documents related to your injury and your workers’ compensation claim, as well as any communication with your employer regarding your injury or termination.
- Consult a workers’ comp attorney. Contact an attorney if you believe you were fired in retaliation for your injury or claim. They can advise you on your legal rights and potential options, such as filing a complaint or pursuing a wrongful termination lawsuit.
Are you located in Great Falls and facing an employment issue related to a work injury?
Murphy Law Firm’s team of workers’ compensation attorneys can help.
Call us today or schedule your free consultation online to get started.
A Guide to Navigating Discrimination Claims in Montana
Facing discrimination? This guide breaks down Montana’s Human Rights Act and explains how to file a claim with the Human Rights Bureau.
